· Webinar recap · 7 min read
How to clean up your ATS data: A 4-step plan for candidate records you can reuse
Tim Sackett's plan for fresher ATS data: define current, prioritize talent pools, refresh records on every conversation, and measure rediscovery.
From the webinar Your ATS Data Sucks. Your Recruiters Are Taking the Blame. We All Lose.
Tim Sackett, CEO, HRU Technical Resources

The short answer
You can't keep every ATS record current, so don't try. Define current as contactable, prioritize the talent pools that support upcoming hiring, refresh key fields every time a recruiter talks to a candidate, and audit a sample of records regularly. Then measure candidate rediscovery to prove the database is worth maintaining.
Tim Sackett was born into recruiting: his mother founded the staffing firm he now runs 46 years ago, and he still manages a team of recruiters working reqs. He also demos more than 150 recruiting products a year. His message in this session, built on Aptitude Research's The Confidence Gap: ATS data has always been messy, recruiters pay for it every day, and fixing it takes a process, not a one-time cleanup.
The confidence gap in ATS data
People feel good about their data. The day-to-day experience of using it tells a different story.
| Finding | Respondents |
|---|---|
| Very or extremely confident the candidate data their team uses is accurate and current | 74% |
| Believe at least a quarter of their ATS records are out of date | 61% |
| Say email messages to candidates bounce often or sometimes | 73% |
| Spend four or more hours a week validating and correcting candidate information | 61% |
| Report a significant negative impact on time to fill from inaccurate data | 35% |
Source: Aptitude Research, The Confidence Gap, 2026. Read the research summary
“Confidence is a feeling. Verification is a process.”
Aptitude Research, The Confidence Gap
The cost isn't only time. When a recruiter can't reach a strong candidate, they move on to the next one, who may not be as good. Bad data changes who gets hired.
The 4-step plan: capture, verify, refresh, reuse
| Step | What it means | Where teams stand |
|---|---|---|
| Capture | Collect contact and profile data when candidates apply | Getting better as apply flows improve |
| Verify | Confirm the person is reachable and responds | Harder as AI tools apply to jobs for candidates |
| Refresh | Keep the most important records current over time | Difficult, because recruiters rarely have time |
| Reuse | Rediscover past candidates before starting new searches | The biggest gap: most teams start every search from scratch |
Tim compares an ATS to a fresh fruit warehouse. Candidates arrive ready to go, and the longer they sit untouched, the more the inventory spoils.
Define what current actually means
Keeping 100,000 records current is impossible. Start with contactability: if you reach out, will the person respond, even with a no? Tim tells his team their job is to get a yes or a no, and silence is neither. His recruiters reach out up to nine times, which he says gets a response from about 93% of people.
Track last verified separately from last contacted. A recruiter may have emailed someone this week, but the last real conversation about where they work, their skills, and what they want could be two years old.
Prioritize the records that matter
Don't try to clean the whole database. Keep fresh the pools that support current and upcoming hiring:
- Finalists and strong candidates you didn't hire
- Candidates who declined offers or withdrew over timing
- People with skills for recurring, hard-to-fill roles
- Alumni who did the job well, not only the top performers
Give each pool an owner, usually a recruiter who hires for that skill set again and again, and limit each recruiter to one or two pools, supported by automation. Tim has even hired summer interns to clean specific pools.
Audit twice a year, as coaching
Tim's team audits twice a year. Operations pulls a random sample of each recruiter's reqs and submittals, and they review the records together in 30-minute sessions over about a day. The goal is development, not punishment: consistent tags and terms (his team still hears "transmittal" from recruiters who learned it a decade ago), correct merges of duplicate records, and shared lessons afterward. Learn how your ATS merges duplicates, since some keep the oldest record even when the newer data is better.
Make every conversation a refresh
Free checklist: Update these three things on every candidate conversation
- Contact details: is this the email and phone they want to be reached on?
- Current job title, in the terms your team searches for
- Interest: are they open to a move, and what pay and location would it take?
Keep required fields short enough that recruiters will actually maintain them. Decide what candidates can update about themselves in your ATS; that's a configuration setting, not custom work.
| Candidate group | When to refresh |
|---|---|
| In an active hiring process | Every interaction |
| Priority talent pools | Quarterly review |
| Asked to reconnect later | A reminder before the date they gave |
| Bounced email or failed phone | Find new details right away, or remove the record |
| Everyone else | Automated outreach about twice a year |
“Contact data ages like fish, not wine.”
Tim Sackett
Earn fresh information with relevant outreach
"Is this still your email?" gets ignored. Outreach should give people a reason to reply: a specific role in the location they mentioned, or news about upcoming hiring. Tim shares the idea that a great recruiter may simply be someone with a thousand people who know them and respond.
Respect communication preferences. In research Tim did with Madeline Laurano, most candidates said they want first contact by email and prefer text or phone once they're interested, even though text messages drew the highest response rates. Ask candidates how they want to hear from you, and record it in the ATS.
Measure whether the database pays off
- Share of priority records verified within their refresh window
- Successful contact rate
- Candidate response rate
- Qualified candidates rediscovered
- Interviews and hires from existing records
If you track one number, Tim recommends candidate rediscovery. On project RPO work, his team makes about 40% of its hires from the client's own database, while clients typically tell him only 5% of their hires come from there. The difference: his recruiters start every search in the database.
How to get recruiters on board
Tim's answer: maintaining key records is part of the job, and it takes minutes a day, not hours. Recruiters can propose a better process, but they can't opt out of the one the team uses. He frames it as data governance, not data policing, and he coaches rather than punishes. His recruiters tend to stay for years.
Where AI fits
Tim expects every ATS to gain agentic workflows that refresh records with relevant outreach, flag right away when a recruiter skips updating a record after a real conversation, and keep reaching out until a candidate gives a clear yes or no. Stronger candidate relationships also help with fraud, from embellished resumes to people misrepresenting who they are.
Takeaways by role
Jump to: Recruiters · TA leaders · HR leaders
For recruiters and sourcers
- Update contact details, title, and interest every time you talk to a candidate.
- Keep your talent pool small enough to maintain.
- Don't treat silence as a no; keep reaching out until you get an answer.
- Search your own database before starting a search from scratch.
For TA leaders
- Define current as contactable, and track last verified separately.
- Assign talent pool owners for recurring roles.
- Run randomized audits twice a year as coaching sessions.
- Make candidate rediscovery your headline metric.
For HR leaders
- Inaccurate data slows time to fill and raises cost per hire.
- Set data governance standards everyone follows.
- Review what candidates can update about themselves in your ATS.
- Use relationship-based recruiting to reduce hiring fraud risk.
FAQ
How do you keep ATS data clean?
Treat it as an ongoing process: refresh key fields after every candidate conversation, keep priority pools current on a schedule, and audit a sample of records twice a year.
How often should candidate records be refreshed?
At every interaction for active candidates, quarterly for priority talent pools, and about twice a year through automated outreach for everyone else.
What does verified candidate data mean?
For Tim, it means you've confirmed the contact details work: you reached out and heard back from the actual person.
What is candidate rediscovery?
Finding and hiring qualified candidates who are already in your ATS instead of starting every search from scratch. Tim recommends it as the main measure of a database's value.
How many times should a recruiter contact a candidate?
Tim's team reaches out up to nine times to get a clear yes or no. After that, he says, the return drops off sharply.
How do you get recruiters to update the ATS?
Make it part of the job, keep required fields short, and use audits for coaching rather than punishment.
About Tim Sackett
Tim SackettCEO, HRU Technical Resources
Tim is CEO of HRU Technical Resources, the staffing firm his mother founded 46 years ago. He is senior faculty for talent acquisition at the Josh Bersin Academy, author of The Talent Fix, and co-host of the Frontlines podcast with Madeline Laurano.
More webinar recaps
- Webinar recap · October 27, 2026: How to hire with purpose: Intake questions and search tactics that go beyond job titles
- Webinar recap · November 10, 2026: How to prioritize open reqs: 6 signals recruiters use to stack rank roles
- Webinar recap · September 29, 2026: Why AI recruiting agents need verified candidate data
- Research · Aptitude Research: The Confidence Gap: Why verified data is the foundation of modern recruiting
- Upcoming webinar · December 1, 2026: The Talent Advocate Strategy: How recruiters align candidate aspirations with the right role


